Doggoly

Breed how-to · Border Collie · 1–2 weeks

How to Teach a Border Collie to Drop It

Reviewed by Sarah Mitchell, CPDT-KA · Updated

The short answer

Turn releasing into a trade: while your dog holds a toy, present a treat at their nose — the moment the jaw opens, say 'drop it,' pay, and give the toy right back. The dog learns that opening their mouth makes good things happen and they usually keep the item too, so there's nothing to guard.

Difficulty
Time
1–2 weeks
Method
Positive reinforcement (trade games)

Why this works for Border Collies

Teaching drop it to a Border Collie plays to the breed's strengths — exceptionally trainable and intense, they typically pick up new cues near the fast end of the 1–2 weeks range. Being a very high-energy breed, a Border Collie learns best after light exercise has taken the edge off — a fizzing dog can't think.

Border Collie trait profile

Energy5/5
Trainability5/5
Barkiness3/5

Drop it prevents resource guarding, ends keep-away games, and gets dangerous items out of your dog's mouth without a fight. Combined with 'leave it,' it covers both ends of the grabbing problem.

Step-by-step: teaching your Border Collie to drop it

  1. 1. Trade with a boring toy

    Play gently with a mid-value toy. Present a good treat at the nose. When the mouth opens, mark, pay, and — crucially — hand the toy right back.

    Tip Giving the item back most of the time is the secret. The dog learns dropping loses nothing.

  2. 2. Add the cue

    Say 'drop it' just before presenting the treat. After a dozen reps, test the words alone — most dogs spit the toy in anticipation.

  3. 3. Raise the item value slowly

    Progress from boring toy → favorite toy → chews → food-adjacent finds. Match your payment to the item: the better the prize, the better your trade.

  4. 4. Practice during real play

    Mix drop-its into fetch and tug. Drop it, pay or re-throw, game continues. The cue becomes part of the fun rather than the end of it.

  5. 5. Emergency-proof it

    Occasionally practice with mildly exciting "forbidden" planted items on walks (a sock, a bread crust in a wrapper). Huge payday for dropping.

Common mistakes Border Collie owners make

  • Chasing the dog — it turns theft into the best game in the house.
  • Prying the mouth open, which teaches dogs to clamp down or swallow faster.
  • Only cueing drop-it when you're confiscating something forever, so it always predicts loss.
  • Trading so rarely the dog decides holding on is the better deal.

Border Collie breed notes

Border Collie note

Motion is a Border Collie's drug: cars, bikes, joggers, and other dogs trigger the herding sequence (eye, stalk, chase), which is why leash reactivity in collies often looks different from fear-based cases — treat it with distance work plus a legal outlet for the instinct. Physical exercise alone doesn't tire them; a collie can run all day. It's the thinking that satisfies.

Want the full picture of what makes this breed tick? See the complete Border Collie training guide or the all-breeds drop it guide.

Border Collie drop it FAQs

Related guides

Train · All breedsHow to Teach a Dog 'Drop It'Turn releasing into a trade: while your dog holds a toy, present a treat at their nose — the moment the jaw opens, say 'drop it,' pay, and give the toy right back. The dog learns that opening their mouth makes good things happen and they usually keep the item too, so there's nothing to guard.
Labrador RetrieverHow to Teach a Labrador Retriever to Drop ItThe world's favorite family dog for a reason: biddable, sociable, and famously food-motivated. The flip side is a long, boisterous adolescence — expect pulling, jumping, and chewing until the brain catches up with the body.
Golden RetrieverHow to Teach a Golden Retriever to Drop ItSoft-natured, handler-focused, and endlessly willing — Goldens are among the most trainable dogs alive. Their main challenges are exuberant greetings, a mouth that wants to carry everything, and enough sociability to make recall around other dogs a genuine project.

Your personal AI dog trainer, in your pocket

Day-by-day training plans built for your dog's breed, age, and problem — with progress tracking that keeps you consistent.

Get the appiOS · Android